The increasing role of AI in grading and assessment has sparked concerns about fairness, reliability, and ethical grading practices in AI-infused learning environments. However, findings remain inconclusive, as AI assistance does not necessarily diminish learning outcomes, raising concerns about the long-term effects on student success and assessment credibility . The Machine learning ability to generate polished AI-driven responses has also contributed to the increasing submission of work that students do not create, thus undermining the authenticity of assessments 68, 72, 85, 86. Conversely, other students view AI as legitimate support tools that are accessible for anyone to use .
The “Against, Avoid, Adopt, https://aicurated.com/ and Explore” (AAAE) framework proposed by designing assessments that AI cannot easily complete, such as reflective writing and oral evaluations. Without structured policies, AI continues to be misused, leading to concerns about the quality of higher education in AI-driven learning environments. Additionally, AI-assisted assessments may create an unfair academic playing field by benefiting students with better access to AI tools and technology while disadvantaging those from underprivileged backgrounds 62, 64, 97.
These tools allow students to automatically generate essays, reports, and coding solutions, increasing the risk of plagiarism and contract cheating 55, 56, 79,80,81. The study followed the six (6) steps of thematic analysis by Braun and Clarke (2006). The initial search across three databases, Scopus (20), IEEE Xplore (300), and ScienceDirect (65), yielded a total of 385 records.
About this article
AI Risks Reducing Peer Exchange and Eroding Collaboration, New DEC and Pearson Report Finds Faculty Support and Resource Basket by the DEC Business School Deans Working Group This study did not require ethical approval as it is a systematic review of publicly available literature and did not involve human participants or animal subjects. Author 2 contributed to conceptualisation, drafting the discussion of findings, writing the original draft, and refining the manuscript. A key limitation of the study has been over-reliance on literature, most https://aicurated.com/ai-applications/new-hope-soleburys-ai-plan-starts-with-how-students-learn/ of which has voices from educators at the forefront of challenges encountered in AI-infused teaching environments. However, to maintain academic integrity, AI-assisted feedback mechanisms must be designed to support rather than replace instructor-led evaluations 66, 91.
Related Articles
AI is forcing Canadian universities to rethink student assessment – Policy Options
AI is forcing Canadian universities to rethink student assessment.
Posted: Fri, 12 Jun 2026 07:00:00 GMT source
GenAI uses algorithms to access this dataset and make predictions about how to string words together, putting one word in front of another based on statistical probability, much like an enhanced predictive text or the autocomplete function of a search engine (Floridi, 2023). Behind every published article stand expert reviewers safeguarding science. Any product that may be evaluated in this article or claim that may be made by its manufacturer is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher. The author(s) declare that no financial support was received for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article. Developed by data science the Digital Education Council and Pearson, this global report presents the first comprehensive mapping of AI-integrated assessment practices in higher education.
This was supported by formative workshops in the responsible use of AI, followed by peer evaluation and final submission without further AI assistance. The impact of GenAI provides an opportunity to rethink assessment strategies so that students demonstrate their knowledge, skill and learning, whilst accommodating the potentially prolific use of GenAI. McMurtrie (2022) argues that GenAI tools will become part of everyday writing in some shape or form, in the same way that calculators and computers have become part of maths and science. This article has considered how traditional assessments can be redesigned to accommodate the advent of AI into the educational arena, allowing educators to feel assured that learning is being assessed and that individual students are demonstrating their knowledge and application of that knowledge. Providing a clear rationale for assessment conditions will help students to see the value in responsible uses of AI technologies. Educators should clearly communicate details about student responsibilities, including whether and how citation should be completed.
Additional access options:
The evolving nature of AI tools and technologies requires open and ongoing communication with students around the permissibility of AI tools to ensure responsible use. To ensure that it is our students completing assessments and demonstrating their learning, assignments and assessments should be constructed in such a way that they are challenging to complete using AI tools or by copying from external sources (Rudolph et al., 2023). Equally, though, GenAI can support learning when used legitimately – for example, to help with grammar and spelling or as a search tool ChatGPT to research assignment topics.
- They can be especially valuable for supporting individual students, addressing disabilities and aligning AI activities with specific learning objectives.
- The table below links to prompt collections that can help teachers in elementary, middle and high school, as well as in higher ed and administrative roles.
- This thoughtful approach will help prepare learners for a future where AI is an essential element of teaching, learning and professional practice.
- This section examines how teens are using the tool and how schools are responding with detection strategies.
- Taught by practitioner faculty, the curriculum is tailored so educators can immediately apply what they learn in their own classrooms and communities.
Keeping Student Learning at the Center
From a pragmatic perspective, our study asserts that Artificial intelligence constructivist learning theory holds significant potential in redefining assessments within an AI-infused learning environment. While AI tools offer the potential for improved outcomes, they also present risks to the authenticity of assessments, potentially undermining academic integrity. This study is grounded in constructivist learning theory, which asserts that learners construct knowledge through engagement with real-world experiences. To navigate these challenges, institutions should adopt a hybrid assessment model that integrates AI while preserving human oversight, ensuring fair and context-sensitive evaluations. Additionally, AI can provide personalised feedback, guiding students towards ethical writing practices and self-regulated learning . We also examine potential strategies to uphold academic integrity and the credibility of assessments for academic evaluations.
AI and Feedback: A New Frontier for Learning Support
Furthermore, some scholars have called for the expansion of AI literacy training as a means of addressing the challenges posed by inappropriate or uninformed AI use 73, 75, 86, 95, 101. These policies establish clear governance structures that define acceptable AI use, ensuring that AI tools support learning rather than facilitate misconduct 54, 57. The absence of formalised AI usage policies in many institutions has resulted in inconsistencies in enforcing academic integrity standards.